Skip

Mathematical physics · 5 manuscript(s)

Positive-temperature Bose–Einstein condensation and exact quantum depletion

Verified by Lean
Open on GitHub

1 · The essentials

These manuscripts study a three-dimensional gas of quantum particles and ask whether a positive share of them can occupy the same spatially constant state. This shared occupation is called Bose–Einstein condensation. In the main model, particles cannot come closer than a fixed exclusion distance. At every sufficiently small fixed density, the main result establishes condensation at some strictly positive temperature that does not shrink as the container grows. The conclusion concerns the exact equilibrium state, not just an approximate description. At zero temperature, companion manuscripts describe how many particles remain outside the shared state, including the leading formula as the gas becomes more dilute. The main result has a Lean formalization, but the supplied information does not specify which additional claims, if any, that formalization covers.

A picture to help (an imperfect image, not to be taken literally)

As an imperfect image, imagine a growing choir in which a positive share of the singers keep singing one common part. Condensation concerns that shared part, while depletion counts those outside it; unlike singers, the particles here occupy quantum states rather than choosing musical roles.

Why it matters

The positive-temperature result concerns the exact canonical equilibrium state and keeps the temperature independent of volume, so the conclusion survives the large-system limit. The zero-temperature manuscripts go beyond a positive condensate fraction by giving the leading amount outside the constant state. Together, the results connect the existence of condensation with a quantitative account of depletion under explicitly stated interaction and density assumptions.

2 · Going further

The main problem concerns the exact canonical Gibbs state of a three-dimensional hard-sphere Bose gas. For each fixed exclusion distance and every sufficiently small fixed density , the main result establishes a temperature , independent of volume, at which the thermodynamic-limit condensate fraction is positive. The occupied condensate orbital is constant in space. The fixed-density condition is essential: dilution is not being used to change the density while taking this large-system limit.

At zero temperature, Manuscript 2 shows in the manuscript the full scaled Bogoliubov momentum distribution of depleted particles for hard spheres, uniformly over pure and mixed ground states. The thermodynamic limit is taken first at each fixed density, followed by the dilute limit. All thermodynamic accumulation values have the same dilute asymptotic, and the limiting scaled nonzero-momentum occupation measure has total mass . Consequently, the depletion fraction is .

Manuscript 3 shows in the manuscript the same leading depletion law for fixed bounded, nonnegative, radial, finite-range interactions with positive scattering length . Its assertion is uniform over ground-state density matrices and does not require a unique thermodynamic limit of the occupation. Manuscript 4 supplies a complementary density-uniform lower condensate bound for fixed bounded measurable, nonnegative, radial, finite-range interactions that are not zero almost everywhere, for sufficiently small densities and temperatures . Manuscript 5 shows in the manuscript ground-state condensation for hard spheres, including arbitrary complex ground states, with a positive fraction independent of the sufficiently small gas parameter.

The abstracts organize the family around positive lower condensate bounds and precise dilute asymptotics for particles outside the constant orbital. They do not describe the argument's technical mechanism, so no proof strategy can be reconstructed from the supplied text. The main result has a Lean formalization; the supplied material does not identify its detailed scope or establish formal verification of the companion results.

Useful notions

  • Quantum states and occupation numbers
  • Equilibrium states and ground states
  • Density and interaction range
  • Thermodynamic and dilute limits
  • Leading asymptotic formulas

What was known before / what is new

Before

The source identifies the zero-temperature depletion formula and scaled momentum distribution as Bogoliubov quantities. It does not give a historical account of earlier results or state what was previously established for these exact models.

New

The main contribution is positive-temperature condensation for the exact canonical Gibbs state of the dilute three-dimensional hard-sphere gas, at a temperature independent of volume. The zero-temperature companions show in the manuscripts the leading Bogoliubov depletion law for hard spheres and for the specified bounded repulsive interactions, with the thermodynamic limit preceding dilution. Further companions supply density-uniform condensate bounds for bounded interactions and ground-state condensation for hard spheres.

Limits and assumptions

All results concern three dimensions and the stated dilute regimes. The hard-sphere positive-temperature assertion gives some strictly positive temperature for each fixed exclusion distance and sufficiently small fixed density; the abstract does not give a full temperature range or a critical temperature. The bounded-potential results require their respective boundedness, nonnegativity, radial symmetry, finite-range, and nontriviality or positive-scattering-length assumptions. The depletion formulas are leading dilute asymptotics, not exact formulas at arbitrary density, and the order of limits is thermodynamic first, dilute second. The main result has a Lean formalization, but its detailed scope is not supplied, and formalization of the companions is not specified. The source lists no explicit remaining open problems; in particular, the accumulation-value formulations should not be read as assertions of a unique thermodynamic occupation limit.

Mini glossary

Condensate fraction
—
The fraction of particles occupying the condensate orbital, which is spatially constant in these results.
Quantum depletion
—
The fraction of particles outside the condensate orbital at zero temperature.
Canonical Gibbs state
—
The equilibrium quantum state at a specified temperature and fixed particle number.
Thermodynamic limit
—
The large-system limit in which particle number and volume grow while density remains fixed.
Dilute limit
—
The limit of decreasing density with the interaction fixed, taken after the thermodynamic limit in the depletion results.
Thermodynamic accumulation value
—
A value approached along a sequence of growing systems, without requiring every such sequence to have the same limit.

Keywords : Bose–Einstein condensation · Quantum depletion · Dilute Bose gases

AI-generated explanation based on the manuscript. Unofficial. Refer to the manuscript for the authoritative version.

3 · Technical details and sources

Claim made in the manuscript (source text)

Proves Bose–Einstein condensation for the exact canonical Gibbs state of the three-dimensional hard-sphere gas: each fixed exclusion distance and sufficiently small fixed density admit a strictly positive temperature, independent of volume, with positive condensate fraction in the thermodynamic limit. At zero temperature, proves the Bogoliubov leading quantum-depletion law for hard spheres and fixed bounded nonnegative radial finite-range potentials of positive scattering length, taking the thermodynamic limit before the dilute limit.

Verified by Lean: the Lean software checked the part of the reasoning described below, sometimes only part of the manuscript. This does not mean independent mathematicians have validated the result.

Scope of the Lean formalization (source text)

…

lean/docs/267.md

Manuscripts in this family

★

Bose–Einstein condensation at positive temperature in the dilute hard-sphere gas

05/10/2026
To be verified

We prove Bose–Einstein condensation at positive temperature in the three-dimensional dilute hard-sphere gas. For each fixed exclusion distance and every sufficiently small fixed density, there is a strictly positive temperature, independent of the volume, at which the exact canonical Gibbs state has a positive condensate fraction in the thermodynamic limit. The condensate occupies the constant orbital.

2.

Quantum Depletion and Momentum Distribution in the Dilute Hard-Sphere Bose Gas

05/10/2026
To be verified

We prove the full scaled Bogoliubov momentum distribution for the depleted particles in the three-dimensional hard-sphere Bose gas at zero temperature. The thermodynamic limit is taken at each fixed density before the dilute limit, uniformly over all pure and mixed ground states. All thermodynamic accumulation values have the same dilute asymptotic: the limiting nonzero-momentum occupation measure has total mass , giving the depletion fraction for density ρ and hard-sphere exclusion distance a.

3.

Quantum Depletion for Fixed Bounded Repulsive Potentials

05/10/2026
To be verified

We prove the Bogoliubov quantum-depletion asymptotic for the ground state of a three-dimensional Bose gas with a fixed bounded, nonnegative, radial interaction of finite range and positive scattering length a. The thermodynamic limit is taken at each fixed density ρ before the dilute limit. Every thermodynamic accumulation value of the fraction outside the constant mode is as . The assertion is uniform over ground-state density matrices and does not require the occupation to have a unique thermodynamic limit.

4.

A density-uniform condensate bound for dilute Bose gases

27/09/2026
To be verified

For each fixed bounded measurable, nonnegative, radial interaction of finite range in three dimensions that is not zero almost everywhere, we prove a positive lower bound on the constant-orbital condensate fraction that is uniform over all sufficiently small densities and all temperatures between zero and the square of the density. The interaction and density remain fixed in the thermodynamic limit.

5.

Ground-state condensation in the dilute hard-sphere gas

24/09/2026
To be verified

We prove Bose–Einstein condensation in every ground state of a dilute three-dimensional hard-sphere Bose gas. At every sufficiently small fixed gas parameter, the constant orbital contains a positive fraction of the particles in the thermodynamic limit. The fraction can be chosen independently of the gas parameter, and the conclusion holds for arbitrary complex ground states.